In early 2014, Robert Caldwell partnered up with Tony Bellatto and Jaclyn Sears, just months after his split with Christian Eiroa and their Wynwood Cigars brand. The new project that brought the three together again was Impromptu, a line of limited edition cigars that Caldwell found in various factories as he was traveling, and released with catchy names and packaging.

The first releases consisted of One Night Stand, Back Door Bambi, Lost Reserve and Pepper Creme Soda, the last of which is the exact same blend as the Cream Machine, albeit in a 5 x 50 robusto vitola.

Cream Machine Bundle

One of the new releases under the brand for 2015, Cream Machine is a 6 x 50 toro that is composed of a Ecuadoran Brazilian-seed Arapiraca wrapper covering a Dominican piloto binder and Dominican Piloto, Dominican Cuban-seed HVA and Dominican habano filler tobaccos. The release is sold in bundles of either three or nine that strongly resemble orange ice cream bars, complete with popsicle stick jutting from the side of the bundle. The release is limited to 1,800 cigars, with the MSRP of each coming it at $12.

The factory has not been disclosed, but some writing by Bellatto on the wrapping of the bundle has this to say:

These cigars are a limited production of well aged cigars that Caldwell found while traveling through the Dominican Republic. I found them fascinating and we decided to share them with you. There is a very small quantity of them so enjoy them while they’re around.

Lost Found Buck 15 Cream Machine Holy Braille SilentShoutThere have been four different Lost&Found releases so far this year, although more are on the way:

  • Buck 15 (5 x 50) — $10 (Bundles of 4, $40) — 100 Bundles of 4 Cigars (400 Total Cigars)
  • Cream Machine (6 x 50) — $12 (Bundles of 3, $36) — 600 Bundles of 3 Cigars (1,800 Total Cigars)
  • Holy Braille (5 x 50) — $15 (Bundles of 3, $45) — 333 Bundles of 3 Cigars (999 Total Cigars)
  • SilentShout (4 x 42) — $5.40 (Bundles of 5, $22) — 600 Bundles of 5 Cigars (3,000 Total Cigars)

Cream Machine 1

  • Cigar Reviewed: Cream Machine
  • Country of Origin: Dominican Republic
  • Factory: n/a
  • Wrapper: Ecuadoran Brazilian-seed Arapiraca
  • Binder: Dominican Piloto
  • Filler: Dominican Piloto, Dominican HVA & Dominican Habano
  • Size: 6 Inches
  • Ring Gauge: 50
  • Vitola: Toro
  • MSRP: $12 (Bundles of 3, $36 & Bundles of 9, $108)
  • Date Released: Feb. 25, 2015
  • Number of Cigars Released: 600 Bundles of 3 Cigars (1,800 Total Cigars)
  • Number of Cigars Smoked for Review: 2

The Cream Machine comes without a band and is covered in a orange-brown wrapper that is smooth to the touch, with just a touch of oil present. There are some very obvious veins present that run down the entire length of the cigar, and a slight box-press is visible. Aroma from the wrapper is a combination of gentle cedar, creamy nuts, sweet chocolate and white pepper, while the cold draw brings flavors of oak, cinnamon, hay, earth and nutmeg.

The Supreme Creme starts off the first third with a dominant oak and leather combination, interspersed with hay, barnyard and peanuts. The profile is quite creamy overall, and I am getting a slight white pepper on the retrohale as well. I am noticing a mushroom flavor that is only present on the finish that seems to be gaining strength as the first third continues, along with a slight nutmeg sweetness. The draw is excellent, and while the burn is not razor sharp, it is not bad enough to need touching up yet. The overall strength is low, barely making it past the mild mark by the end of the first third.

Cream Machine 2

While the profile remains creamy, the dominant flavor shifts in the second third of the Supreme Creme to more of a peanut note that is present on both the palate and the finish. Other flavors of earth, barnyard, oak, espresso and cocoa flit in and out, along with quite a bit more of the mushroom flavor from the first third. There is a slight graham cracker sweetness on the retrohale that combines nicely with some white pepper that I am noticing as well, and smoke production is still above average. Construction-wise, the draw is fine, but the burn is a bit wavy, although still within normal limits. The strength has increased, but finishes the second third just shy of the medium mark.

Cream Machine 3

The mushroom flavor from the second third has continued to gain strength, and becomes the dominant flavor in the profile by the start of the final third of the Cream Machine. I am tasting other flavors as well, including earth, leather, bitter espresso, cocoa and grass, and there is still a noticeable white pepper on the retrohale. The graham cracker sweetness is still quite noticeable on the finish, but it is still not strong enough to become the dominant flavor. The burn and draw continue along the same path as the second third, as does the smoke production, and the strength finally hits the medium mark before the end of the cigar, but stalls out there.

Cream Machine 4

Final Notes

  • The wrapper on this release is extremely fragile, and both both samples had issues at the cap where I used my v-cutter, although they were not bad enough to cause problems with the actual smoking.
  • I am not sure how I feel about how these cigars are marketed and released. While I applaud the idea of repurposing cigars that were never released for one reason or another, doing nothing but rereleasing a blend that has already been available on the market seems odd to me.
  • Having said the above, I am impressed with the ideas behind some of the packaging and marketing of some of these releases, including Impromptu Supreme Creme. SilentShout—which is basically just a craft paper bundle with a stamp on it—not so much.
  • The packaging for the 5 x 50 Pepper Cream Soda was a simple paper craft  bundle wrapped in twine.
  • This looks and tastes like a Davidoff release to me, although the somewhat average construction would confound me if that was the case.
  • In January 2015, the Impromptu brand was renamed BCS — for Bellatto/Caldwell/Sears — before being renamed again roughly a month later to Lost&Found.
  • There is also a limit of 20 retailers who will carry the Lost & Found project.
  • It has been said, but it bears repeating: the Lost&Found project is independent of both Caldwell Cigar Co. and La Barba Cigars.
  • The cigars smoked for this review were purchased by halfwheel.
  • The final smoking time for both samples averaged one hour and 35 minutes.
81 Overall Score

There is no denying that the Impromptu Cream Machine is quite smooth, nor can I deny that it is full of flavor. However, as with other releases that have similar profiles, the mushroom note that became significantly more prominent after the first half was strong enough to take way a lot of my enjoyment in the cigar overall. The construction was fine—albeit closer to average than stellar—and the smoke production was a nice surprise. In the end, if you like that musky mushroom flavor in cigars, this is a release you will want to track down, but if you want a stick with a balanced profile, this is not for you.

Brooks Whittington

I have been smoking cigars for over eight years. A documentary wedding photographer by trade, I spent seven years as a photojournalist for the Dallas Morning News and the Fort Worth Star Telegram. I started the cigar blog SmokingStogie in 2008 after realizing that there was a need for a cigar blog with better photographs and more in-depth information about each release. SmokingStogie quickly became one of the more influential cigar blogs on the internet, known for reviewing preproduction, prerelease, rare, extremely hard-to-find and expensive cigars. I am a co-founder of halfwheel and now serve as an editor for halfwheel.