Cigar Lovers — This list is divided into five geographic regions each of which are awarded five ranked cigars. The five first place cigars were awarded 23 points, the five second place cigars were awarded 18 points, etc.
ComedyCigarsMusic — This list was 25 unranked cigars, meaning all cigars received 13 points for a 25-way tie.
Dads Smoking Cigars — There were two separate lists of 10 cigars. The two first place cigars were awarded 24.5 points, second place 22.5 points, etc.
Developing Palates — This list had a tie for 25th place, meaning there were 26 cigars. Given the cut-off 25 cigars, those cigars were not included though it doesn’t appear it would have changed the final results.
Smokin n’ Lead — There were two separate lists of five cigars. The two first place cigars were awarded 24.5 points, second place 22.5 points, etc.
Smokers Spot — There were eight cigars on this list, meaning each cigar was awarded 20.5 points.
Stogie Press — Confusingly, this list divides cigars into three categories—small, medium, large—and then ranks the top 15 in each. The top eight cigars in each category were listed for The Consensus. Each first place cigar received 23 points, second 20 points, etc.
Ted & Karl’s Cigar Review — There were two separate lists of five cigars. The two first place cigars were awarded 24.5 points, second place 22.5 points, etc.
The Average Joe’s Cigar Reviews — The Tatuaje WCD 127 was placed at both 15th and 17th. I gave it the points for 15th place and then just bumped up every cigar from 17th place on one spot.
The Cigar Smoking Man — There were 13 cigars listed, meaning a 15-way tie for eighth place.
