The Consensus 2019 Lists

  1. 99 Cigars
  2. Blind Man’s Puff
  3. Bob The Cigar Guy
  4. Casas Fumando
  5. Cigar & Spirits
  6. Cigar Aficionado
  7. Cigar Artistry
  8. Cigar Coop — This list has 30 cigars, only the top 25 were counted.
  9. Cigar Dojo
  10. Cigar Journal
  11. Cigar Prop — There are two lists, meaning points were divided by two.
  12. Cigar Snob
  13. Cigar Talk with Pats
  14. Cigar Vixen
  15. CigarBible
  16. CigarCraig
  17. Cigarguide — Because of the relationship between Cigarguide & Ministry of Cigars, the points were divided by two.
  18. Cigars Lover — This list is divided into five sections. Cigars from the first section were given 23 points, second section 18, etc.
  19. Dads Smoking Cigars
  20. Developing Palates — There are four separate lists published, as such each entry is divided by 4.
  21. halfwheel
  22. High Desert Man
  23. Hot Ticket Podcast
  24. How Bout That Cigar
  25. iRobusto — This is four different lists, however, two are top 10 and the other two are top 25. Points for each list were divided by four.
  26. Jonose Cigars
  27. Kaplowitz — There was a tie for first, both cigars were awarded 24.5 points.
  28. Katman
  29. Martín Amaya
  30. Ministry of Cigars — Because of the relationship between Cigarguide & Ministry of Cigars, the points were divided by two.
  31. Robb Report — This list included seven cigars, unranked. Each cigar was awarded 22 points, a 7-way time for fourth.
  32. Should I Smoke This? — There were actually eight cigars on this list.
  33. Smoke n’Lead — There are two lists, meaning points were divided by two.
  34. Stogie Bink
  35. Stogie Guys — This list included seven cigars, unranked. Each cigar was awarded 22 points, a 7-way time for fourth.
  36. Stogie Press
  37. The Burn Down — There were eight cigars, meaning each was ordered 21.5 points.
  38. Tiny Tim
  39. Tuesday Night Cigar Club — There is a three-way tie for first between various Neanderthal sizes. Because there isn’t a blend difference, these cigars were just listed as “Neanderthal.” There was however a two-way tie for 7th, meaning this list is actually a Top 11.