The Consensus 2019 Lists
99 Cigars
Blind Man’s Puff
Bob The Cigar Guy
Casas Fumando
Cigar & Spirits
Cigar Aficionado
Cigar Artistry
Cigar Coop — This list has 30 cigars, only the top 25 were counted.
Cigar Dojo
Cigar Journal
Cigar Prop — There are two lists, meaning points were divided by two.
Cigar Snob
Cigar Talk with Pats
Cigar Vixen
CigarBible
CigarCraig
Cigarguide — Because of the relationship between Cigarguide & Ministry of Cigars, the points were divided by two.
Cigars Lover — This list is divided into five sections. Cigars from the first section were given 23 points, second section 18, etc.
Dads Smoking Cigars
Developing Palates — There are four separate lists published, as such each entry is divided by 4.
halfwheel
High Desert Man
Hot Ticket Podcast
How Bout That Cigar
iRobusto — This is four different lists, however, two are top 10 and the other two are top 25. Points for each list were divided by four.
Jonose Cigars
Kaplowitz — There was a tie for first, both cigars were awarded 24.5 points.
Katman
Martín Amaya
Ministry of Cigars — Because of the relationship between Cigarguide & Ministry of Cigars, the points were divided by two.
Robb Report — This list included seven cigars, unranked. Each cigar was awarded 22 points, a 7-way time for fourth.
Should I Smoke This? — There were actually eight cigars on this list.
Smoke n’Lead — There are two lists, meaning points were divided by two.
Stogie Bink
Stogie Guys — This list included seven cigars, unranked. Each cigar was awarded 22 points, a 7-way time for fourth.
Stogie Press
The Burn Down — There were eight cigars, meaning each was ordered 21.5 points.
Tiny Tim
Tuesday Night Cigar Club — There is a three-way tie for first between various Neanderthal sizes. Because there isn’t a blend difference, these cigars were just listed as “Neanderthal.” There was however a two-way tie for 7th, meaning this list is actually a Top 11.
Navigation
Retail Sponsors
About