Earlier this year, Altadis U.S.A. began shipping a new limited edition Montecristo that carried a decent price tag, bold claims and some unique packaging.

The cigar is the Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch. As the name implies, it’s described as the cigar made privately for Altadis U.S.A.’s Grupo de Maestros, a six-person team made up of managers of Altadis U.S.A.’s Tabacalera de García factory in La Romana, Dominican Republic. Javier Elmudesi, who is the manager of Tabacalera de García, heads the Grupo de Maestros, which also includes Victor Avila, Nestor Rodriguez, Candido Rosario, Carlos Travieso and Pedro Ventura. Each has their own roles within the factory, but collectively they are part of the blending team at Altadis U.S.A., as well as a growing part of the company’s marketing.

As for the cigar, it uses an Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper grown by the Oliva Tobacco Co., a olor binder grown in Villa Gonzáles, Dominican Republic from the 2010 vintage and filler tobaccos from Nicaragua: 2010 Jalapa criollo ’98 viso and Jalapa corojo ’99 ligero.

The cigars are packed in 100-count bulk boxes that Tabacalera de García actually uses in its aging room. The Montecristo Grupo de Maestros is packed in one of these cedar boxes with five trays of 20 cigars inside.

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch Box 1

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch Box 2

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch Box 3

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch Box 4

Each box also comes with a more traditional cigar box that contains a certificate of authenticity and other documents.

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch Box 5

The cigars began shipping last month.

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch 1

  • Cigar Reviewed: Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch
  • Country of Origin: Dominican Republic
  • Factory: Tabacalera de García
  • Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra
  • Binder: Dominican Olor
  • Filler: Nicaragua (Jalapa Criollo ’98 & Corojo ’99)
  • Size: 6
  • Ring Gauge: 54
  • Vitola: Toro Extra
  • MSRP: $15 (Boxes of 100, $1,500)
  • Date Released: Jan. 8, 2015
  • Number of Cigars Released: 250 Boxes of 100 Cigars (25,000 Total Cigars)
  • Number of Cigars Smoked for Review: 3

The Ecuadorian wrapper is uniform in its dark brown color with a bit of roughness—something that I think adds to the overall look of the release. Aroma-wise, I get some acidic leather and burnt cedar from the wrapper with the foot giving off large amounts of meatiness, vanilla and some creamy orange flavors. I have to cut a bit passed beyond my normal cutting point due to how the cap is filled. Even after the cold draw is somewhat tight with mild flavors of cherry, coffee, leather and some sea salts.

While it doesn’t last long, the smoke production is somewhat anemic to begin with on the first two samples. Once I take a puff, things change completely and the room is quickly filled with grey smoke from both ends of the Montecristo. Flavor-wise, I get dry woods, leather, sweet milk chocolate and a lot of white pepper. After the first puff, there’s a ton of smoke and quite a bit of nicotine, solidly in the medium-full range. The Montecristo Grupo de Maestro has a fair bit of nuttiness and cedar in the mouth with lemon, a heartier cedar, hickory and Worcestershire sauce through the nose; unfortunately, there’s also a bit of harshness upfront. The ash is even and firm, and the draw has loosened up to the midpoint, but the cigar is burning hot, although not in the way it normally happens. While the smoke is a bit warmer, the actual cylindrical roll of tobacco is very hot at around an inch and a half up from the burn line.

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch 2

Into the second third and there’s a subtle sweetness that’s developing on the tongue. It’s way more aggressive through the nose with a Dr. Pepper-like cherry sweetness joining lemons, some mushroom flavors and a gritty harshness. Unfortunately, the harshness also remains. Two of the samples I smoked are burning a tad hot and there’s some harshness in the back of the throat now as well. Strength remains at medium-full, but the body recedes so the nicotine comes off as significantly less aggressive than the first third.

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch 3

The final third of the Montecristo Grupo de Maestros sees the nuttiness overtake the rest of the medium-plus profile. While there’s lemon, mushroom and even a bit of cocoa, a plethora of freshly chopped nuts is all over the mouth and nose. Strength increases to just south of full, something I honestly was expecting to happen much earlier on in the cigar, which never does get to full. While the cigar remains well above average in terms of physical temperature, the burn, draw and smoke production all remain great until the end.

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch 4

Final Notes

  • If you, like Patrick Lagreid, are wondering why Montecristo was chosen for this project versus Romeo y Julieta, H. Upmann, Trinidad VegaFina or any of the other brands from Altadis U.S.A., we got two different answers. At one point, we were told that the tobaccos used are similar to what goes into some Montecristo blends, something that doesn’t seem particularly likely. Later we were told that it was simply a marketing choice.
  • Speaking of Montecristo, the brand, it turns 80 this year.
  • The Grupo de Maestros concept reminds me a lot of Oliva’s STUDIO TOBAC. Both programs were launched after the departure of a singular high-profile face. In the case of Oliva, it was Sam Leccia, as for Altadis U.S.A., the concept was introduced about a year after José Seijas left.
  • One sample I smoked was underfilled a bit below the midway point, this definitely did not help the heat issue. That being said, another well-filled sample burned equally as hot, while the third sample was quite normal.
  • Much will—and should—be made about the box, but I think Altadis U.S.A. nailed the look of the cigar itself. The off-white faded secondary bands, the classic-looking Montecristo band and the deep brown, but not oily, wrapper combined to given an appearance that works.
  • The secondary bands are actually unique to each box. They should read “Caja x/250” depending on the box number. The samples for this review came from a not for sale box.
  • Each box is going to be very unique. Not just because the box and bands will have a different number, but each box has lived a completely different life in the factory. In the case of Patrick Lagreid’s box, there wasn’t just names and other words on it, but also some interesting math equations.

Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch Box Math

  • While I do love the box, if you don’t have a large cabinet humidor or a cooler, don’t think about picking these up.
  • Davidoff did somewhat of a similar thing a few years ago when it shipped excess stock of the Zino Davidoff 100th Anniversary Robusto. It shipped the cigars not in the boxes used to age, but rather the boxes it uses to ship cigars from the Dominican Republic to the U.S.
  • For those wondering, I’m fairly certain these are not the actual boxes that were used to age these 100 cigars. A representative from Altadis U.S.A told us they spent a bit of time trying to find the boxes to use for the cigars. In addition, the cigars are aged prior to color sorting and banding, meaning that if this box actually aged the 100 cigars that it shipped with, the normal process of how a cigar is made would have gone a lot differently.
  • All three samples I smoked required deeper cuts than I normally perform. It’s not an issue of tightness, rather, there’s a lot of tobacco towards the top of the cap.
  • Whether or not the Grupo de Maestros smoke this regularly is a question I suspect we will never get an answer to. When you work a factory controlling blends, the idea of regularly smoking any one cigar seems highly unusual.
  • This is the strongest cigar I’ve smoked from Altadis U.S.A. and a far cry from lines like Montecristo White or Classic.
  • Cigars for this review were provided by Altadis U.S.A. to halfwheel.
  • Smoke production was about as much as I’ve had on any cigar in recent memory.

A while back, I reviewed the H. Upmann 1844 Reserve Special Edition. It was awful. Terrible in just about every way. In that review, I made the claim that there’s no way the people who blend cigars at Altadis U.S.A. would smoke the cigars I smoked for a review, and I wondered what they smoked.

86 Overall Score

There are a lot of Altadis  U.S.A. touches on the cigar from the tobacco to the marketing, but there’s also a lot that’s different. It’s a full cigar, it’s most certainly not aimed at Altadis U.S.A.’s typical customers and despite a hefty price point, I’d actually buy a few more—to sit on them. My big issue with the cigar is that for most of the cigar, particularly the first two-thirds, there’s a harshness that sits at the front of the tongue. While it’s not the dominant flavor by any means, it’s easily recognizable because of its positioning on the palate. I think a few months and probably a day or two of dyboxing will help this and the heat issue that is inevitably associated with the harshness—and after that, I imagine the Grupo de Maestros will be a very good cigar.

Avatar photo

Charlie Minato

I am an editor and co-founder of halfwheel.com/Rueda Media, LLC. I previously co-founded and published TheCigarFeed, one of the two predecessors of halfwheel. I handle the editing of our written content, the majority of the technical aspects of the site and work with the rest of our staff on content management, business development and more. I’ve lived in most corners of the country and now entering my second stint in Dallas, Texas. I enjoy boxing, headphones, the Le Mans 24-hour, wearing sweatshirts year-round and gyros. echte liebe.