- Blind Man’s Puff
- Casas Fumando (Jeremy Hensley)
- Casas Fumando (Tony Casas)
- Cigar & Spirits
- Cigar Aficionado
- Cigar Craig
- Cigar Dojo
- Cigar Federation
- Cigar Journal
- Cigar Snob
- Cigar Vixen
- Cigar-Coop/Stogie Geeks[ref]Cigar Coop and Stogie Geeks are both part of Stogie Geeks, LLC. As such, there’s list were combined like a singular website which publishes multiple lists. Cigar-Coop’s list was not published in its entirety by the time The Consensus was published.[/ref]
- Developing Palates
- Kohnhed
- Leaf Enthusiast (Jon Siddle)[ref]Leaf Enthusiast’s David Jones published a list, however, because he works for Burn’s Tobacconist his list is not included.[/ref]
- Leaf Enthusiast (Keith Hollar)
- Stogie Guys[ref]This list is divided up into two lists, four in one and 12 in the other. The four cigars “tied” for first and were awarded 23.5 points, while the other cigars (5-16) received 14.5 points each.[/ref]
- Stogie Review (Ben Lee)
- Tiny Tim
- Toasted Foot
- Tuesday Night Cigar Club
Note: Any list that used user votes to produce the results was excluded. In addition, at least one list was excluded because it ranked 25 cigars into groups of five countries, something that was impossible to determine statistically for the purpose of this list.
As always, there are lists that likely didn’t make it on here because they were not published or I was unaware of their existence.
