THE LISTS
- acigarsmoker.com
- Birmingham Cigars
- Blowin’ Smoke
- Blue Lizard Cigar Lounge
- Casas Fumando
- Casas Fumando (Average Joe)
- Casual Cigar
- Chief Hava
- Cigar Aficionado
- Cigar Brief (Anthony C.)
- Cigar Brief (Jason)
- Cigar Brief (Paul)
- Cigar Dojo
- Cigar Inspector
- Cigar Journal
- Cigar King
- Cigar Psychology
- Cigar Snob
- Cigar-Coop
- Covering Your Ash (Brian Coyne)
- Covering Your Ash (Jason Zahner)
- halfwheel
- Highlight Cigars
- James Suckling
- Keeping Your Man Card (Frank)
- Keeping Your Man Card (Pat)
- Keeping Your Man Card (Poppa P)
- kuziscigarcatalog
- Leaf and Grape
- longfillerlounge (fusco)
- longfillerlounge (TC)
- Mike’s Stogies (Mike)
- Mike’s Stogies (Young Buck)
- MyCigarBlog
- NiceTightAsh (Shawn)
- Scott Smyth
- Seth’s Humidor
- StickReview
- Stogie Review (Ben)
- Stogie Review (Brian)
- Stogie Review (Charlie)
- Stogie Review (Jerry Cruz)
- Stogie Review (Mike)
- Stogie Review (Walt)
- StogieFresh
- StogieNet
- Talking Tobacco
- The Perfect Draw
- The Smoking Greek
- TheGarShop (Mayor)
- TikiBar (David Jones)
- Toasted Foot
- Tom’s Cigars
NOTES ABOUT THE LIST
- Blue Lizard Lounge:
- Four Kicks & Headley Grange were both listed as a tie for first. 34.5 points, the average between first and second were awarded to both.
- Cigars listed 2-6 were relisted as 3-7.
- There were two cigars listed for seventh place. Both were awarded 27.5 points, the average between 8th and 9th.
- Cigars listed 8-10 were relisted as 10-12.
- Casa Fumando (Average Joe) — Two cigars were listed in fourth place. As such 31.5 points was awarded to each and the following cigars on the list ranked from 6th-11th.
- Chief Hava — All of his RoMa Craft Tobac products, which were unordered and in a separate “Honorable Mentions” post were excluded.
- Leaf And Grape — The “Best of the Best” list was used in place of a confusing averaging system of the three lists.
- Nice Tight Ash (Shawn) — 35 points was awarded to “Cigar of the Year.” The other 10 cigars listed were awarded 29.5 points, the average of 2-11 places.
- Stogie Review (Ben):
- Aquitaine, CroMagnon and Intemperance were listed as third place. 32 points (the average of 3-5 places were given to each.)
- Cigars listed fourth and five were listed as six and seven.
- The Tatuaje Little Monsters were listed in sixth place. 27 points were awarded to each of the five cigars (the average of 8-12 places.)
- Cigars listed 7-10 were ranked 13-16.
- Stogie Review (Mike) — 35 Points were awarded to the Emilio AF Suave for #1. The remaining nine cigars were awarded 30 points, a nine-way tie for second place.
- The Perfect Draw — Two cigars were listed as tied for number one. As such the Tatuaje Avion ’11 & Litto Gomez Diez 2012 Chisel were awarded 34.5 points.