It is likely that there will never be a year quite like 2016 for The Consensus.
The difference between first and second? One point. The difference between 25th and 26th? A half point—of which three cigars were tied—missing the list by a half point. That being said, there was a consensus. The cigars that finished first and second appeared on over half the lists used to produce this year’s version of The Consensus, an incredible feat in consistency.