In 1999, 5th Avenue Products Trading GmbH, the German distributor for Habanos S.A. celebrated its tenth anniversary as the exclusive distributor of Cuban cigars for the region.

The name actually started in 1976 as 5th Avenue Tobacco Gallerie, a retail operation. However in, 1989, Villiger Söhne Holding AG (Villiger Group), the soon-to-be 126-year-old Swiss company, and Cubatabaco, the predecessor to Habanos S.A., used the name to describe a joint-venture that would be the exclusive distributor for cigars in Germany.

As far as the cigar goes, the10 Jahre 5TH Avenue, which literally translates into 10 years 5TH Avenue, was a special Julietas No.2 (7 x 47) specially-banded and packed in Michel Perrenoud humidors of 50. Only 100 humidors were made, selling for 3,800 DEM (around $2,650 today).

This ad/press image shows the humidors:


The humidors featured the logos of all brands distributed by 5th Avenue, which included non-Cuban brands like Toraño.

10 Jahre 5TH Avenue 1

  • Cigar Reviewed: 10 Jahre 5TH Avenue
  • Country of Origin: Cuba
  • Factory: n/a
  • Wrapper: Cuba
  • Binder: Cuba
  • Filler: Cuba
  • Size: 7
  • Ring Gauge: 47
  • Vitola: Churchill
  • MSRP: $53.00 (Humidors of 50, $2,650.00)
  • Date Released: 1999
  • Number of Cigars Released: 100 Humidors of 50 Cigars (5,000 Total Cigars)
  • Number of Cigars Smoked For Review: 1

There’s very few veins on the wrapper of what appears to be a well-rolled cigar. The mustard-colored wrapper has little aroma, sweet peanut and hay. From the foot, I pick up some notes that would not be too unexpected for Cubans: hay sugar and a touch of barnyard. The 5th Avenue release continues to provide little surprises on the cold draw: huge twang, hay and a very interesting contrasting saltiness and sourness.

While the cold draw is most certainly tight, the first third of the 10 Jahre is much better. There’s a medium burnt hickory note, some saltiness mid-tongue and some mustiness. I was expecting a lot more sweetness, but there’s none to be had, the finish delivers some burnt notes and saltiness. It’s clear from the get go this is going to be a quicker churchill as the cigar is burning quickly. Twenty minutes in and I can tell you things have most certainly changed: crisp Worcestershire sauce and some greasiness up front, sourdough underneath and a finish that delivers just a touch of sweetness on the back of the throat. The retrohale is where the cigar shines though, floral and lemon zest.

10 Jahre 5TH Avenue 2

There is no question this cigar was probably tasting better a few years ago, the mustiness on the tongue is at times overwhelming, but elsewhere, there’s some excellent attributes, including the construction. The draw is great, the ash is beautiful and the burn is as good as any cigar I’ve smoked in the past six months. Some harshness and grassy notes make their way onto the tongue, but the sweetness is increasing, which makes it a bit more palatable. As it crosses the halfway, some fragrant citrus soap notes emerge, along with more saltiness. Fortunately, the mustiness begins to fade, albeit leaving more harshness exposed.

10 Jahre 5TH Avenue 3

Unfortunately, the final third of the 5th Avenue anniversary sees the mustiness return. There’s a generic meaty note that crept into the retrohale in the latter half of the second third that is much more noticeable as the cigar goes on with salty peanuts now the main flavor on the tongue. As had been the modus operandi from the start, the flavor is getting more intense until I set it down.

Final Notes:

  • The cigar is rumored to be based on the Romeo y Julieta Churchill.
  • 5th Avenue has recently started distributing in Austria.
  • Cigar Journal has a great article about the history of Villiger here.
  • Villiger is actually able to import Cuban tobacco thanks to its relationship with Cuba. It also is associated with Intertabak A.G., the Swiss distributor for Habanos S.A.
  • In 2005, the 5th Avenue received a 15th anniversary cigar, the Vegas Robaina Robaina. The toro-sized cigar is arguably the first Edición Regional, although it featured a completely different band.
  • At this point, I imagine Habanos S.A. will use the Edición Regional series to satisfy distributor anniversaries, but who knows.
  • If you have questions about construction, see below:
  • Strength-wise, there’s little nicotine to speak of. That said the flavor is most certainly full and body is medium plus.
  • There’s not a whole lot of these floating around. In 2010, C.Gars Ltd had 19 cigars at £635.
  • This Art of Smoke article indicates that an empty humidor was being offered for €1,250.
  • I absolutely love this size, but too often I find myself wondering why the size gets overfilled.
  • Cigars for this review were purchased by Brooks Whittington.
  • Final smoking time was a relatively quick one hour and 35 minutes.
89 Overall Score

If you are not retrohaling this cigar, do not bother smoking it. There’s no question in my mind this cigar is not going to get better in terms of the mustiness that is oftentimes too much during the 5th Avenue 10th anniversary, but if you are not going to retrohale the cigar, there’s little pleasure here. There’s a lot to really love about this cigar: amazing construction, a wonderful retrohale and some strong flavors from a near 15-year-old cigar. But there’s also the mustiness, the harshness and a lack of cohesiveness when it came to the flavor profile. I would smoke this cigar again, probably spend $25 for another one, but it’s hard to refer to this in any sense as classic Havana. A time machine to 2004 would probably do wonders.

Charlie Minato

I am an editor and co-founder of Media, LLC. I previously co-founded and published TheCigarFeed, one of the two predecessors of halfwheel. I handle the editing of our written content, the majority of the technical aspects of the site and work with the rest of our staff on content management, business development and more. I’ve lived in most corners of the country and now entering my second stint in Dallas, Texas. I enjoy boxing, headphones, the Le Mans 24-hour, wearing sweatshirts year-round and gyros. echte liebe.