Review: E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino


Today we will be taking a look at a cigar we had planned on reviewing back when it came out in April, but decided to hold it for this week, the E.P. Carrillo Elencos! In Late 2010 E.P. Carrillo, released their Edición Limitada, a 6 x 54 Double Robusto sporting a Brazilian Habano wrapper with only 1000 boxes of 10 produced. (You can read the review of the E.P. Carrillo Edición Limitada 2010 HERE.) The cigar was very well received and took a spot on top ten lists all over the internet. Very soon after the release there were rumors of the cigars blend being turned into its own line with different vitolas offered. Everyone waited in anticipation until the news was concrete. Indeed in early 2011 it was announced that the Elencos line was soon to be released taking the name from which the 2010 Edición Limitada vitola was named. The cigar is comprised of the exact same blend as the 2010 Edición Limitada and available in three vitolas:

 

  • Don Rubino – 5 ¼ x 50
  • Elites – 6 x 54
  • Acto Mayor – 6 ¼ x 52 (Belicoso)

The Elencos come packaged in one of the nicest boxes I have seen lately, a glossy black wooden cabinet with a flip top lid and hinge made of excellent quality. Here are some photos of the Don Rubino box:

E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino 1.png

E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino 2.png

E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino 3.png

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

Let’s get to the review shall we?

E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino 4.png

  • Cigar Reviewed: E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino
  • Country of Origin: Dominican Republic
  • Factory: Tabacalera La Alianza S.A.
  • Wrapper: Brazilian Habano
  • Binder: Dominican Republic
  • Filler: Nicaragua
  • Size: 5 1/4
  • Ring Gauge: 50
  • Vitola: Robusto
  • MSRP: $9.50 (Boxes of 20, $190)
  • Release Date: April 2010
  • Number of Cigars Smoked for Review: 5

Visually the cigar is quite perfect; it has a medium chocolate colored wrapper with minimal oil and a rough, tacky feel to it. There are very few veins and the cigar is packed very well with a seamless wrap and a nice triple cap. The pre light aroma is full of sweetness, just nice rich tobacco sweetness with notes of coffee, cocoa and hay. The pre light draw is full of chocolate along with smooth cedar and hay.

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

Starting off in the First Third, I get a touch of spice and pepper, through the nose and on my palate which quickly settles down. Flavors of wood, earth and cocoa fill my mouth. The cigar is very smooth with a woody, peppery finish that last quite a while. Cigar is medium body but rising.

E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino 5.png

Coming into the Second Third the sweetness of the cigar builds up showing a rich caramel like sweetness that mixes well with the thick, creamy smoke feel. The profile is still mainly a smooth woodiness with a bit of dark chocolate, coffee and earth. There’s a lot of earth on the finish, as well as a nice pepper kick that rushes along my tongue and down my throat. The cigar is balanced well and is building in body to a medium/full. The construction is wonderful with the ash holding on into the second third.

E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino 6.png

Finishing up in the Final Third the cigar switches up a little bit with a touch of an airy floral note, like a dried flower type aroma. It doesn’t show so much in the actual flavor but in the aroma which adds a nice contrast to the sweet, earthy flavor profile. I start to get a touch of leather on the finish towards the end and the wood, earth, coffee and chocolate flavors are mixing very well with everything else. Very balanced and smooth with a medium to full body and medium strength. Construction is top notch.

E.P. Carrillo Elencos Don Rubino 7.png

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

Final Notes:

  • I smoked about 5 samples of this cigar for this review and only one of them had slight construction issues, other than that they were perfect. On the one I took photos of as you can see the ash held on for more than half the stick!
  • This cigar had a wonderful complex, balanced profile with a wonderful aroma as well. In some ways I found this to surpass the 2010 Edición Limitada despite the blend being the same. It seemed a bit more refined and a touch smoother. I also smoked the Acto Mayor Vitola (Belicoso) and found that one to be just as good, however I am not a huge fan of Belicosos to I chose this one for the review.
  • I have gotten word from Ernie himself that he will be releasing a Maduro version of this line come 2012 with one of the vitolas being introduced along with the 2011 Edición Limitada at IPCPR in Las Vegas this July.
  • If you want to purchase any of the EPC Elencos, (or any of the EPC sticks!), our Sponsors are always willing to help! Contact Call Mark at Tower Cigars at (916) 443-8466, Hal at Empire Cigars at (919) 870-0081 or Jeff at Tobacco Grove at (763) 494-6688, and tell them we sent you, and they will be happy to take care of you!
  • Final Smoke time was 1 hour 5 mins…

_______________________________________________________________________

 

The Bottom Line: This could very well be my favorite E.P Carrillo cigar to date. It offers a profile full of flavor, balance and the right amount of added spice and pepper. This cigar does not kick your ass in the nicotine department but it has a really nice medium to full body with thick, creamy smoke and a great mouth feel. This is one of Ernie’s higher priced regular production cigars, but when you smoke one you know where the money is going, you can definitely tell this is using top notch, high quality tobacco. There is a lot of great tobacco coming out of Brazil lately and this Habano wrapper is a testament to that. If you haven’t tried this yet I suggest you do because E.P Carrillo hit the nail on the head with this one… again.

 

 

Final Score: 91

71 comments
usmcxlv
usmcxlv

Excellent review. I'm at the halfway point; your comments resonate with my experience. 

Stu DeWitt
Stu DeWitt

I've been a huge fan of Carrillo's sticks since be first started. Used to get the La Gloria Torpedo Maduros for $25.00 a box.
Can't wait to try the newest line!!

HabanoHam
HabanoHam

Great Review Steve! That's a pretty nice ash on the second from last shot

Ben SS
Ben SS

Beautiful presentation on these; I think this convinced me to pick up some :)

Foe
Foe

Beautiful. Lovin' the EPC reviews!

johnny
johnny

can't wait to smoke one.

bowhnter
bowhnter

Another good review, thanks

LennyM
LennyM

I LOVED the EL 2010 so I'm glad to hear it's now in full-time production!

Thanks for the great review!

toddk
toddk

Wow, these look great... can't wait to try one. Thanks for the review.

Sarge
Sarge

another great review~!! Can't wait to get my hands on some of these to try.

Robert
Robert

Nice review of a great cigar. Probably my favorite of EPC's regular lines as well. Now, if only my local shops would get some in stock!

tundrahi
tundrahi

That is one great looking wrapper!

J.A.S.
J.A.S.

I just procured a couple "Don Rubino" to try and seems like it will be worthwhile!

hawgmauler
hawgmauler

Havent heard of this one, will have to look for it

Andy K
Andy K

Thanks for the review. Sounds like a winner.

ChrisM
ChrisM

The 2010 EL was a great smoke. I'll definitely be picking up some Elencos.

Tim
Tim

Great review. Thanks

T_ron99
T_ron99

Crazy good looking ash on a great looking cigar!

Thanks for the review Steve.

Kyle M
Kyle M

Another day, another interesting sounding EPC, and another obnoxious comment from me.

t money
t money

Again..I want to try them all!

George
George

Great review! EPC quickly becoming one of my everyday smokes!

Nate
Nate

Mmmmmm... Elencos, this reminds me I need to order some more!

CP Staley
CP Staley

The box alone makes me want to try this cigar...but the great review doesn't hurt either....

theant
theant

Once again thanks for the reviews and thanks for the contests.

Alex K
Alex K

another great stick that I need to try

JayL
JayL

Sick ash ! Good job, Steve.

Matt
Matt

I'm glad you liked it. I picked up a few when Ernesto was promoting these as pre-release. Can't wait to try them they have been around for months in the humi.

Alec
Alec

dig the label

amsgpwarrior
amsgpwarrior

I've been sitting on samples of the Elencos for about a month now and haven't gotten around to doing my review on them. Can't wait to smoke them after this review. Good work Patrick! Just picked me up a Golosos (2010) and smoking it now.

MSD002
MSD002

This is a great smoke and a great review. Thanks again for this week!

Tequila_D
Tequila_D

Great review! This sounds awesome.
Can't wait to to try it.

greg6326
greg6326

brazilian habano sounds tasty......

pmai
pmai

Though the price is out of my comfort zone and the RG is a little big for me, I will probably try a few anyways. Thanks for the review and contest.

Cateacher
Cateacher

Great review and pics. Ash was sweet!

Mutombo
Mutombo

Yet another EPC cigar I need to try...

vipernpa
vipernpa

I have one left of the 2010 Limited Edition. I'm glad he decided to make the blend a regular production!

JwyAtt55
JwyAtt55

Have one of these tucked away somewhere. Need to dig her out and try for myself! Great review.

Kaz646
Kaz646

Ernesto just can't put out a bad product. Everything he does just says class. Great review though! Can't wait to get my hands on some

mike c
mike c

I think a call to Tower is in order!

Dbell
Dbell

That box is a keeper for all things secret

jake79
jake79

This one going on the buy list for sure!

Ryan
Ryan

Loving the ash, but the RGs are too big. Pass for me...

Joe45
Joe45

Great review, Steve. Looks like I now my next purchase!

Kris
Kris

I have the toro size resting right now. I hope it is as good as your review!